2012 player grades

[Boondock Saint]

Originally Posted by TDog

He didn't come close to that this year, and he was a miserable failure. Suggesting that he would be a failure even if he put up Miguel Cabrera numbers misrepresents the position of those who would prefer he didn't create a black hole in the White Sox lineup, which is exactly what a player who hits less than .220 and strikes out more than 220 in a season presents.

Batting average doesn't win you games, RBI's do. He had 96 of those, best on the team.