Originally Posted by TaylorStSox
Probably because, aside from BA and RBI, all his numbers are superior and he's played 4 less years.
I'm not sneering at PK's numbers. He's had a great career. I also call it like I see it. There's a small group of posters here that like to pretend Dunn hasn't also had a great career.
But you have to understand all his good years were before he joined the Sox. His three years here have been a disappointment to me. Unlike other Dunn critics, I was fine with the signing when it happened. I've been proven wrong.
And, yes, I do know that Dunn was the most productive hitter for the Sox last season. For me, that says more about the rest of the lineup than it says about Dunn. He was the most productive hitter for the worst Sox offense and worst Sox team in my lifetime. Damning with faint praise.