Originally Posted by WhiteSox5187
Define fringe, I think he sticks around on the ballot for awhile but I don't think he gets in.
I would define fringe as Keith Hernandez. Was on the ballot for 9 years, never got more than 10% of the vote. Won 1 MVP, 11 gold gloves, has a higher career WAR, has 1 more WS ring (not that it should matter) than Konerko. To me, that is fringe, and Paulie is below that.