Peavy is NOT a #2 pitcher on a contender- he's barely over .500 in 4 seasons in the AL with a 4.00+ ERA- CAN be very effective in short stretches when he's healthy- but I think a contender would view him as #3 at best.
He was 4-7, 4.00 ERA in the 2nd half last year- if he can prove he's healthy- his value will be highest at this trading deadline- vs. holding on to him for next year.
With Sale, Santiago, Quintana, Danks, E. Johnson (AAA)- I think we can have solid rotation without him- so if we can get decent value- I say go for it.
2005-2013 Record: 49-38
MLB Parks Visited: 24
MiLB Parks Visited: 11