Originally Posted by shingo10
He couldn't close and it wasn't because he didn't have good enough stuff...which leads me to believe that he doesn't have the make up to pitch in tight ball games.
A guy who was dominant in a setup role gets moved to closer and has struggled ever since. I don't see it as a coincidence.
So, "he doesn't have the make up to pitch in tight ball games," but he was also "dominant in a setup role."