Originally Posted by dickallen15
Peavy pitched 50 more innings than Fister last year and had a lower ERA. He was injured the year before, but appears to be healthy and did win the Cy Young once, so if Fister is an ace, you would have to call Jake one, but of course the Tigers are the greatest team ever assembled.
You are honestly saying Peavy isn't a huge question mark compared to Fister? Come on man, take the blinders off. Peavy's been hurt on and off every year he's been hear except last year. Even if Peavy's still an ace (debatable), he's not nearly has valuable as the Tigers front four, who are either just as good or better, and certainly way more durable.