Quote:
Originally Posted by sullythered
Gary Carter was not better than Pudge. Piazza was a better hitter, but who's to say why <taps nose>.
|
Gary Carter in 19 seasons
66.4 war
11 allstars
4 top 10 mvps
5 silver sluggers
Carlton Fisk in 24 seasons
63.7 war
11 allstars
3 top 10 mvps
3 silver sluggers
I would pick Carter but its not a huge differance. Carter was a much better defensive catcher too.