have to disagree with a few. . .
Crain - should be lower- not as dependable as his salary dicates
Peavy - is paid like an ace (see Verlander) pitched well but not ace-like
Sale - don't know how he doesn't merit an A
Paulie- C is too critical, yes, he struggled down the stretch, but I think injury prevented him from being as effective as he might have been. . . B or B-
Beckham saved a lot of runs with his defense, especially with DP's. Granted, his offense isn't where we liked or expected, have you looked at AL secondbaseman???? should be at least a C overall. .
That's my two cents worth. . .