Originally Posted by oeo
What's your definition of perennial then? I'm mostly referring to Buehrle (3x), Maggs (6x), and Carlos Lee (3x).
Buerhle's made it three times? Oh, I forgot about '06. And I forgot about Lee entirely. To me though "perennial All Star" means "one of the best guys at their position" and while I think a case could be made for Maggs and Lee (now that he is in the NL) I don't think I'd include Buerhle on that list.