PDA

View Full Version : Rate the AL Central by rotation & by pen


SoLongFrank
03-07-2006, 06:36 PM
1-SP
Buehrle
Santana
Rogers
Sabathia
R Hernandez

2-SP
Garcia
Lee
Radke
Elarton
Bonderman

3-SP
Contreras
Silva
Byrd
Maroth
Greinke

4-SP
Garland
Westbrook
The rest don't compare.
Redman
Lohse
Robertson

5-SP
Vazquez
The rest don't compare.
Johnson
Baker
Verlander
Affeldt

Closer
Nathan
Jenks
MacDougal
Wickman
Jones

Setup
Hermanson
Rincon
Cabrera
Rodney
Burgos

Middle
Crain
Politte
Mota
Sisco
Walker

Middle-2
Cotts
Betancourt
Wood
Guerrier
Spurling

Middle-3
McCarthy
Sauerbeck
German
Liriano
Dessens

0o0o0
03-07-2006, 07:15 PM
1-sp
Santana
Buehrle
Sabathia
Rogers
Hernandez
2-sp
Garcia
Lee
Radke
Bonderman
Elarton
3-sp
Contreras
Byrd
Silva
Maroth
Greinke
4-sp
Garland
Westbrook
Lohse
Redman
Robertson
5-sp
Vazquez
Guy on other team
Guy on other team
Guy on other team
Guy on other team
closer
Nathan
Jenks
MacDougal
Wickman
Jones
Setup
Rincon
Hermanson
Cabrera
Rodney
Burgos
Middle
Crain
Cotts
Politte
Betancourt
Sisco

ShoelessJoeS
03-07-2006, 07:28 PM
1-sp
Santana
Buehrle
Sabathia
Rogers
Hernandez
2-sp
Garcia
Lee
Radke
Bonderman
Elarton
3-sp
Contreras
Byrd
Silva
Maroth
Greinke
4-sp
Garland
Westbrook
Lohse
Redman
Robertson
5-sp
Vazquez
Guy on other team
Guy on other team
Guy on other team
Guy on other team
closer
Nathan
Jenks
MacDougal
Wickman
Jones
Setup
Rincon
Hermanson
Cabrera
Rodney
Burgos
Middle
Crain
Cotts
Politte
Betancourt
Sisco
I'd have to agree with the order of your starting pitchers, even though our staff is made up of all 1s and 2s with maybe a 3 thrown in there. However, IMHO (trying to hold back my bias) I think that both Politte and Cotts > Rincon and Crain. Furthermore, I don't know if there is a better righty-lefty combo of set-up men in the majors than CP and NC.

soxfan26
03-07-2006, 09:51 PM
1-SP
Santana

2-SP
Bonderman

3-SP
Contreras

4-SP
Garland

5-SP
Vazquez

Closer
Nathan

oeo
03-07-2006, 09:55 PM
2-SP
Bonderman

There's no way he's the best #2 in the AL Central. This guy hasn't even proven he can win consistently.

I'd take Santana, and our starters for the final four spots (even unbiased). Nathan as closer, as well.

BTW, is Contreras considered a #3 or is he our #2 now? Not that it matters, was just curious though because I can see him on the mound for the ring ceremony.

soxwon
03-07-2006, 10:03 PM
1-SP
Buehrle 2
Santana 1
Rogers 4
Sabathia 3
R Hernandez 5

2-SP
Garcia 1
Lee 5
Radke 2
Elarton 4
Bonderman 3

3-SP
Contreras 1
Silva 2
Byrd 3
Maroth 4
Greinke 5

4-SP
Garland 1
Westbrook 2
The rest don't compare.
Redman 4
Lohse 3
Robertson 5

5-SP
Vazquez 1
The rest don't compare.
Johnson 2
Baker 3
Verlander 5Affeldt 4

Closer
Nathan 1
Jenks 3
MacDougal 4
Wickman 2
Jones 5

Setup
Hermanson3
Rincon 1
Cabrera 2
Rodney4
Burgos5

Middle
Crain 3
Politte 1
Mota 2
Sisco 4
Walker 5

Middle-2
Cotts 2
Betancourt 1
Wood 3
Guerrier 5
Spurling4

Middle-3
McCarthy1
Sauerbeck2
German3
Liriano 4
Dessens5


thats it

Rooney4Prez56
03-08-2006, 11:58 AM
1 SP-Buehrle
2 SP-Garcia
3 SP-Contreras
4 SP-Garland
5 SP-Vasquez

CL - Nathan
SU - Rincon
MRP 1- Politte
MRP 2- Cotts
MRP 3- McCarthy

SoLongFrank
03-08-2006, 02:30 PM
I put Mark over Santana for one reason: health. Santana's already had health problems in the past & I think he remains a bigger risk than Mark in that area.