Given a choice of catchers....

[NUCatsFan]

Alright....not quite sure where to post this, so move it if necessary.

I was listening to sports talk radio out here in the Bay Area and they were saying that there's no one out there (I assume he meant GMs/owners) that would take AJ Pierzynski over Mike Matheny. So, what do you guys think?

[MeanFish]

As much as I like AJ, I wouldn't take him over Mike Matheny.

[doublem23]

On pure talent, Matheny, but for the price, I have to think Matheny is making more than he's worth, while A.J. was a nice, cheap pick-up.

[hose]

Matheny is 34 years old, AJ is 27.