Your bullpen confidence ranking

[chisoxfanatic]

How would you rank our bullpen in terms of your confidence to get the job done? Let's let #1 be the guy you're the most confident in.

My ranking:



Matt Thornton
DJ Carrasco
Bobby Jenks
Octavio Dotel
Randy Williams
Tony Pena
Scott Linebrink

[BadBobbyJenks]

Matt Thornton
Bobby Jenks
Tony Pena
DJ Carrasco
Octavio Dotel
Randy Williams
Scott Linebrink

[Boondock Saint]

Thornton
Jenks
Carrasco
Dotel
Pena
Williams
Linebrink

[kevingrt]

1. Thornton
2. Jenks
3. Carrasco
4. Dotel
5. Pena
6. Williams
7. Nunez
8. Linebrink

[Domeshot17]

Matt Thornton
Bobby Jenks

Please don't put anyone else in any kind of important situation

Carrasco I will give credit guts out his long relief outings, but the guy has gotten really lucky. Usually giving up more hits than IP is a bad thing. He guts it out, but his value is 100% in his ability to go long.

I also know I should have faith in Dotel, but the way the guy crumbled down the stretch last year, He is a 3 run home run waiting to happen, he scares me everytime he comes in.

[thomas35forever]

Matt Thornton
Bobby Jenks
D.J. Carrasco
Octavio Dotel
Tony Pena
Randy Williams
Scott Linebrink

[JB98]

1. Thornton
2. Jenks
3. Carrasco
4. Dotel
5. Linebrink
6. Pena
7. Williams

[slavko]

I have more overall confidence in Thornton than Jenks but I would rather see Jenks closing.

[Noneck]

Thornton
Jenks
Dotel
Pena
Linebrink
Carrasco
Williams


I know he has been huge this year but I keep thinking that soon the crap being slung up there by him is going to start to be hammered.

[wmusox9]

1. Thornton
2. Jenks
3. DJ
4. Dotel
5. Pena
6. Williams
Linebrink

I might even trot a few position players out there before Linebrink at this point.

[nitetrain8601]

1)Thornton


4)Dotel
5)Williams

7)Jenks

9)Linebrink

11)Pena



none if it came down to it: Carrasco